Roth IRA Conversions: Better Late Than Never?

Congress created a new retirement-saving vehicle that became effective in 1998: the Roth IRA. Its primary advantage over a traditional individual retirement account (IRA) is that, although you can’t deduct your contributions and must pay income tax currently on any rollover from an existing IRA, you pay no income tax on qualified distributions. This means your money can grow tax free -- not just tax deferred. Congress also offered a bonus for taxpayers who converted (rolled over) their traditional IRAs into Roth IRAs during 1998 only: They could spread payment of the income tax due on the conversion over four years.

If you missed out on or couldn’t qualify for the initial bonus of the four-year spread, could a conversion of your traditional IRAs to a Roth IRA still make sense? Even though you will have to pay all of the tax in the year of conversion, the answer could well be "yes."

Can You Qualify For a Conversion?
Nothing else will matter if you cannot qualify for conversion. Your adjusted gross income cannot exceed $100,000 to qualify. (Note that the threshold for Roth IRA contributions is different from Roth IRA conversions.)

Even if your income is typically more than $100,000, you may be able to qualify in certain years. For example, if your business has a losing year or you have retired, you may be able to qualify. Talk to us about possible creative ways to defer or accelerate income between years so that you may qualify for a Roth conversion.

The Age Factor
Because Roth funds build up tax-free over time, the Roth IRA works best for young individuals. But younger people who can qualify tend to have smaller balances in their IRAs and may not be able to afford the tax as well.

However, even with small balances, conversion to a Roth IRA is a good idea. You’ll be most likely to benefit from conversion if you are young, can qualify for conversion and can afford the tax.

A conversion is not as beneficial for an older person because fewer years are available for the funds to build up tax-free. Ironically, retired taxpayers often can more easily make the conversion. They may be able to meet the income qualification because they are no longer working, and they often can afford to pay the tax on a substantial IRA balance because they have larger amounts of savings outside of the IRA. If you are retired and will not need some portion of your IRA funds to live on and, even better, have sufficient funds outside the IRA with which to pay the income tax, you are a prime candidate for conversion.

Building a Family Fortune with Your Roth IRA
While the Roth IRA can be effective as a wealth-building strategy for you and/or your spouse if at least one of you lives long enough (say 15 or 20 years), it can also be beneficial for your heirs even if you don’t live that long. That’s because the potential period of tax-free buildup is not limited to your own lifetime.

While the Roth IRA is subject to the same distribution requirements after death as other IRAs and qualified retirement plans, this is when its benefits may prove to be greatest. Your Roth IRA can continue to grow tax-free during your lifetime because there are no required minimum distributions and for many years after you die, because required distributions can then be based on the life expectancy of a much younger child or even grandchild beneficiary.

Running the Numbers
Before jumping into a substantial Roth IRA conversion, carefully project its results and weigh the long-term potential benefits against the current cash outlay needed to pay tax. Look at how it works at different rates of return, too, keeping in mind that some appreciation in value of the Roth IRA assets is key to its benefit as a strategy.

Also, compare its value versus alternative use of the funds necessary to pay the tax. These alternatives might include making gifts to family members if you don’t have sufficient funds to do everything at once.

‘Tis the Season for Roth Conversions

While many income tax planning strategies are best implemented as year-end approaches, conversion to a Roth IRA is best done earlier in the calendar year because it involves the creation of taxable income. If your income would otherwise be the same as last year (or higher), you will not need to pay tax on income from converting a regular IRA to a Roth IRA until April 15 of 2002. And if the value of your IRA keeps growing, the amount includable in taxable income is lower now than it will be on a conversion later in the year.

If you would like more information on whether converting your traditional IRA to a Roth IRA is a smart strategy for you and whether this is the best year to do it — or if you have other retirement or estate planning questions, please call us. We’d be pleased to help you get the most from your IRAs and their assets.



541 North Fairbanks Court > Suite 1700 > Chicago > Illinois > 60611
: 312.321.0300 > : 312.321.0364 > : info@romeassoc.com
Copyright 2002